Given
91%
while driving a
Toyota Corolla
(205/55 R16) on
a combination of roads
for 20,000
spirited miles
2 years ago I bought 4x Bridgestone Weather Control A005s.
I've covered 21k miles on them, rotated the tires once and now all are at 3mm of tread left. My driving is a good mix of motorway and fast, twisty A-roads up in the hills of Lancashire and the car is usually running heavy with people and kit on board.
In wet weather these tires provide plenty of confidence. There is lots of grip for fast driving on twisty roads with plenty in reserve for an emergency situation. When newer they happily tracked through standing water at speed and maintained your position on the road.
On dry roads, in a family car, I think you'd be hard-pressed to notice the difference between these all season tires and some dedicated summer tires regarding grip levels and steering precision.
I've had a few opportunities to drive on snow but no more than 2 to 4 inches deep. Fresh snow posed no real issues with gaining traction, even up moderate inclines. However, compacted snow showed the tire's weakness whilst getting moving on slight uphill sections. Additionally, cornering grip ran out much earlier than expected.
As an example, out in the sticks I had to make a right turn into a wide open junction on a mix of packed snow and slush. I was probably going 12mph, if that, and the tires failed to follow the moderate amount of steering lock applied and skittered almost straight on towards the kerb. To prevent an expensive bit of wheel and suspension damage I hit the brakes and the ABS must've pulsed about 30 times to slow the car enough to allow the tires to grip again. The tires probably had about 5-6mm of tread at that time.
I was very surprised by the lack of "bite" the tires had on such a little amount of snow, especially given I have turned into this road 1,000s of times in different cars, on various tires and in worse conditions.
Having had cars fitted with Nokian WRA3s, WRD4s, WRD3s, Hankook Winter Icept*RS2s & various Goodyear Vector 4Seasons (Gen 1 & 2) I think the A005s beat them all in the wet and dry. But in the snow, the A005s come in last place by some margin. They're not terrible on snow but traction, braking and cornering are not a patch on the tires listed above.
Noise levels? There are no tiresome noises or irritating droning at motorway speeds. They're a good companion when travelling long distances and comfort levels are high. They seem to absorb road imperfections very well indeed.
Fuel economy? Not noticed any difference between the A005s and the summer tires previously fitted.
Wear? Just over 20k miles (there might be another 5-8k left in them) given the types of roads I drive on I don't think is too bad. The A-road surfaces themselves are rough and scarred and the tires take a lot of punishment in that respect, so I'm happy with that result.
Would I recommend them / buy them again? Definitely, they're fantastic and I'm really happy with them (my wife bought the newer Evo version for her car). The only caveat that might change your mind is if you drive in hilly areas where it snows more frequently than in Lancashire. In which case, all things considered with my experience of the above tires, buy the Goodyear Vector 4Seasons - I feel they're 90% of the A005s in the wet & dry but far superior in the snow.
Just to contradict what I've written above, I'm currently waiting for the arrival of 4 Falken Euroall Season AS210s which will replace the A005s this October / November - I like trying different tires out, you see!