Given
100%
while driving a
Volkswagen Golf Mk6
(205/55 R16 V) on
a combination of roads
for 3,000
average miles
Back in August 2011 I started researching a new set of all-season, winter-rated tires for my wife’s DSG equipped VW Golf Tsi. We decided that having a set of summer and a set of winter tires didn’t fit our requirements and would be too much hassle. Having suffered for years getting stuck in the snow and having to walk over half-a-mile back to our hilltop village, enough was enough.
After 2 months of reading various magazine reviews plus my own internet research I had it narrowed down to 3 options: Vredestein Quatrac 3, Hankook Optimo 4s or Goodyear Vector 4 Seasons. Following reading numerous tests we decided the Goodyear’s suited our needs best.
The internet price per 205/55/16 tire in August was £90 (same as the factory-fitted Michelin Primacy’s) but by the time I ordered all 4 tires in October the price had crept up to £101 per tire.
We had the Goodyear’s fitted locally for £10 each at the start of November and following this my wife reports that the ride is smooth and absorbent with lower noise levels than the previous Michelin’s. Travelling on wet roads through standing water the Goodyear’s are significantly more resistant to aquaplaning and offer noticeably more grip in the corners on cold, wet fast A-roads and motorways.
She’s tried the Goodyear’s on a previous dusting of snow without any problems but the real challenge was during the snow dump on Feb’ 4th 2012.
After a trip out shopping it started to snow but rather than go home to Bury, Lancashire we headed for the A59 North Yorkshire to go to a pub for a relaxing meal to allow the snow to accumulate. As the afternoon progressed we returned to Bury where there was now 2-3 inches of snow on the towns’ roads. Growing in confidence we felt ready for the challenge of getting back to our hilltop village on untreated roads and along the way we would perform a few tests, too.
We started the climb up the hill on 2-3 inches of snow and soon met our 1st victim: a bus performing a 3-point turn and heading back down. Waiting for the bus to get out of the way we realised this would be our 1st hill start on packed snow and the grade was about 1 in 5. Once the bus left my wife hit the accelerator and the car shuffled slightly, but quickly gained traction and we were off – no problem.
Further round the corner the road steepens and then crosses a bridge where there was 4-5 inches of fresh snow – nobody had gotten this far up and it’s now about 1 in 4 incline. We purposely stopped on the bridge and attempted another hill start but this time the intention was to accelerate as hard as possible. The traction control light flickered as the tires searched for grip but we were off and got up to 25mph from a standstill in no time at all at which point we ran out of bravery on the narrow road.
Emergency stops are dealt with just as easily: the car stops very quickly in a straight line with no drama at all, even when heading down steep roads. It was a real eye-opener just how quickly the car was able to stop on fresh snow from 25mph. The only concern we would have doing this is possibly being followed by someone who will likely be on ‘summer’ tires – there is no way they would be able to avoid crashing into us such is the grip generated by the Goodyear tires.
Near the top of the hill, before going to our house, we drove into a large pub car park that is also on a quite a severe slope when covered in snow. Nobody drives too far into this car park in the snow as there would be no chance of recovering your car easily. But this didn’t put us off – we drove in at about 10-15mph and applied the amount of steering lock we would expect to use on a dry day to exit at the top end of the car park. Amazingly, the tires gripped and tracked the route we were hoping to stick to without needing to apply any more steering lock - no skidding or scrabbling for grip.
Bottom line: we wanted some truly all-season tires that wouldn’t leave us stranded following a decent snowfall and that would give us total confidence to venture out in such conditions as well as being great in the wet and the dry – we can confirm these tires are fantastic.
Some might say that all-season, winter-rated (3 peaks mountain snowflake on sidewall) tires are a compromise; 90% grip of decent winter tire in the snow and 90% grip of a decent summer tire in warm weather but we feel these tires are worth it for our needs. After all, we’ve not been left stranded in the snow (the main point of buying them) and neither of us drive like Ayrton Senna in the summer so this so-called ‘compromise’ won’t even be noticed.
Given the Goodyears’ cost the same as the factory-fitted Michelin’s (£90), don’t need changing every 6 months like full winter tires, no need to buy a 2nd set of steel wheels to mount the tires, they likely won’t leave you stuck in the snow, are confidence-inspiring in the cold and wet and will be prove more than good enough come the summer, I just don’t see the point of buying ‘summer’ tires again.
My wife was skeptical after the Goodyear’s were fitted – I mean, how could a different set of tires not have her slithering to a stop on snow like the Michelin’s near home and end up her having to walk it? Well, she drives the Golf all the time and drove the car in all the conditions / tests written above (hill starts, cornering and emergency stops on 6 inches of snow) and she says she never wants summer-rubber again and has insisted on another set of Goodyear Vector 4 Seasons when these wear out – praise indeed.