Michelin Primacy 4 Plus Reviews - Page 2

Given 56% while driving a Toyota Sienna (235/60 R17) on mostly motorways for 80,000 miles
Tires are suppose to last 80,000 so they said on the warranty. Rotated every oil changes. Drove only 30,000 and now need replacement. Too expensive and doesn't back up what the tires advertised. Goodyear or Dunlop are better. Going back to them, they back it up with what the preach. What a disappointment!
Helpful 41 - tire reviewed on April 23, 2023
Given 87% while driving a BMW 335d (225/45 R18) on a combination of roads for 3,000 average miles
I switched to Primacy 4+ from Pilot Sport 4 so I am sharing my experience as a comparison between the two on the same car. The main difference in normal everyday driving is the steering feel. Primacy 4+ is noticeably slower in reactions to steering inputs - it feels less eager to change direction. It makes the car feel generally less agile and does not encourage spirited driving like Pilot sport 4 does. When increased lock is applied there is a signifficantly more progressive centering force with Primacy 4+. I find this most welcome on a BMW F31 with its otherwise quite light steering. The effect is more natural and authentic than the car’s sport mode steering feel (which just makes the wheel unnaturaly heavier). The result is a superior sense of stability at all speeds. Less focus and precision is required to make smooth progress, and high-speed driving is signifficantly more relaxed with Primacy 4. The difference in confidence is further increased in wet. I don’t hear any significant difference in interior tire noise on smooth roads but bumps, potholes, and protruding manhole covers are better smoothed-over and less annoying with Primacy. For spirited driving the Primacy 4+ is not. When pushed harder it just all starts giving in where the Pilot Sport starts to shine. There still is respectable cornering grip with Primacy 4 and traction is more than adequate but you can tell the tires are fighting and there is no reward when pushed hard. My decision to switch from Pilot Sport to Primacy was based on the fact that I have very few daily opportunities for spirited driving. So 95% of the time I am very happy with my decision while the remaining 5% is also dialled back a little and everything is fine. If I had a second car just for fun it would be fitted with Pilot Sport (S), no doubt.
Helpful 41 - tire reviewed on March 22, 2023
Given 67% while driving a Subaru forester 158cv 2.0 auto (225/45 R17) on a combination of roads for 5,000 spirited miles
Dry grip is excellent, can't say the same for wet. Road noise is quite noticeable.
Helpful 29 - tire reviewed on March 19, 2023
What to know the BEST All Season Tires for 2024? Click to find out!
Given 63% while driving a Hyundai Ioniq (195/65 R15) on a combination of roads for 2,000 easy going miles
This tire was fitted to my hybrid car as the e-primacy was not available from Michelin. Originally my vehicle was fitted with Energy Saver tires which regularly gave me in excess of 70 mpg. These tires have not been able to achieve 60 mpg on a regular basis.
Helpful 35 - tire reviewed on February 1, 2023
Given 87% while driving a SEAT Leon (225/40 R18) on mostly motorways for 3,000 spirited miles
I've had these on all round on a PHEV SEAT Leon for around 3,000 miles now, before I had the from factory Bridgestone Potenza S005.

Driving in the icy/snowy conditions seen just before Christmas 2022, these tires gave me more confidence in control and handling, as the Bridgestone's often struggled for grip in the dry let alone the cold and wet.

The grip so far has been an extreme improvement, the Bridgestone's would often spin under the power of a PHEV in all conditions, despite trying my hardest, it is difficult to replicate with the 4+ from a standing start.

There has been a lot of rain lately, and with the 4+, there is a significant reduction in the slippery feeling when passing over standing water, particularly at motorway speeds.

The tires have also improved the slip/lean feeling on roundabouts. It feels as if they are listening to the direction I want to go, and I know that they are complying.

I've not noticed a difference in braking performance - seem standard for a premium tire, and time will tell if they deflect nails and are not magnet for them like the Potenza's.

Noise seems average. Potholes feel harsher.
Helpful 35 - tire reviewed on January 14, 2023
Given 96% while driving a MINI Mini Countryman Cooper Petrol (225/60 R16) on a combination of roads for 1,000 spirited miles
Trust me, these michelin primacy 4+ tires: 205/60 r16 96H XL on the front of my Mini countryman 1.6 are the better tire than the bridgestone XL on the rear . these Michelins are improved version of the Primacy 4, more comfort, more feedback and super grip. Always had Michelins on the front wheel drive Mini, worth the little extra cost. Had michelin primacy 4 tires: 205/60 r16 96h xl previously. Those lasted 6 years, a great tire used right down to 1.6 mm with over 50000 miles clocked up with various short and long journey shared with my teenage son. Change can be good and Michelin had done an excellent job with the improvements on the 4 Plus. It's also super quiet, the best and safest Tire around, really.
Helpful 42 - tire reviewed on October 7, 2022
Given 97% while driving a Honda Civic FK7 Sport (235/45 R17) on a combination of roads for 1,000 average miles
Coming from the Civics original tires Primacy 3 that’s lasted 25Kmls or just over 4 years, I don’t do a lot of miles daily but those Primacy 3 tires served me well with just the road noise being a little loud at times I liked the dry, wet, handling and comfort of these Michelin’s.

So with not a lot of info on the new Primacy 4Plus and needing 4tires I decided to go with these anyway as only £1.oo each dearer than the primacy 4 when I purchased, in for a penny in for a pound, these are the XL reinforced version I went for as they are a whole 1DB quieter than the non XL version according to the tire info.

Noise loudness will always be dependent on the surface you drive on, so as surfaces change so does the tire noise but the difference between these Primacy 4Plus and the old Primacy 3 is night and day and worth the price of entry alone in my ears, no they ain’t dead quiet/ silent but are a lot more bearable and not as intrusive, as I’ve went from listening out to hear the difference to now not noticing the noise like I did with the old tires.

Comfort - oh yeah less noise and there’s a softness, definitely more comfortable drive

In the dry the tires are good , nice feedback from the road however sharp corners taken fast pushing the limit there is a give there that you are wary of after the first time, but this will make you safer as you won’t push quite as hard, it’s that softness mentioned earlier that gives you this feeling/ feedback on hairpin bends.

In the wet, love them, it rains in Scotland and the surface water can be a bit deeper and running on the roads in areas, but these Primacy 4 plus, just grip grip and grip and provide a lot of confidence way bettering than the old Primacy 3 on the civic, a tire for Scotland without doubt

The tread is less on the 4 plus than on my new Primacy 3 when got the car but these P4 plus are meant to be harder wearing tire so only time will tell, but if they last 20Kmls or 4 years then I’d be more than happy.

Initial thoughts on first 1Kmls is if you want a premium tire live in a wet summer area and enjoy less noise and improved comfort give these a go.
Helpful 306 - tire reviewed on July 24, 2022
Given 87% while driving a Skoda (225/45 R17) on mostly town for 2,500 average miles
Bought these to replace my Dunlop sport rt2 tires. So this review is based on that. If course the rt2 is a sport tire and I assume these are touring tires .... Safe to assume because they are so so much quieter ( yes very much noticeable) and provide a softer ride. Comforting to know they also perform well as they wear down. No unnecessary wheel spins so they hold grip well . I dont push my car to test tires..... to me that's a an uneccassary risk, however after 2500 miles I've had no worrying moments with the primacy 4+ s . If i were to critisise I don't think the car handles quite as direct now but not by much , but again maybe the difference between sport and touring tires. I've not really had much chance to try these in the rain yet. The old dunolps always wore down fast even though I'm no boy racer. Let's hope there's more life in these michelins. Bought as a great deal between ATS euromaster and paying via a santander bank card for another 10% off.
Helpful 31 - tire reviewed on July 15, 2022
Given 95% while driving a Saab Automobile 9000 Turbo (205/55 R16) on mostly motorways for 0 average miles
205/55 R16 91W weights 8.45kg. Made in Poland. It is funny that it still says "Primacy 4" on the tire, without "+".
Helpful 42 - tire reviewed on July 6, 2022
Given 90% while driving a Skoda (225/45 R17) on a combination of roads for 1,100 average miles
I've replaced my Dunlop rt2s on my skoda octavia with these. The main reason I picked michelin tires was because my Dunlop seemed to wear out fairly quickly. Handling feels the same.... I dont carry out daring braking or driving but they have given me confidence in both conditions and I now drive more confidently with them than my previous tires ..... Thats confident, not drive like an idiot... The one thing I really wanted was quiet tires and these are super quiet, I'm really impressed just how quiet. Not only that but they've also added comfort to the ride. This maybe because they're more of a touring tire than sport tire. For comparison, I rarely do motorway driving, just A roads and city driving. So far so good after just over 1000 miles... Personal tire reviews do bother me, as we can only judge them based on our previous set of tires, and rarely can any retail customer carry out track tests .. But im adamant these are an improvement for me.
Helpful 37 - tire reviewed on May 26, 2022
Given 94% while driving a Volkswagen Passat 1.4 tsi B7 122 BHP (205/55 R16) on mostly motorways for 20,000 miles
Tire is excellent that’s the second pair i purchase from the primacy 4 plus , i’m an aggressive driver who always drive 140+ km/h thanks michelin for letting me feel safe on the road
Helpful 52 - tire reviewed on May 21, 2022
Given 100% while driving a Mercedes Benz A45 S AMG (225/45 R17) on a combination of roads for 0 spirited miles
fantastic tires , oh my god , michelin best brand
Helpful 73 - tire reviewed on April 29, 2022